Lombardi, the oldest pizzeria in the US - NYC, New York

Image of the Sign about Lombardi's Pizza in NYC, New York - the oldest pizzeria in the US
It has been a while since I wanted to go to Lombardi's Pizza, the oldest pizzeria in the US, located in New York City. We went last Saturday and the place was not packed, until 12:30pm where patrons started to come and even had to wait outside! I guess this place is in all the guides, explaining the sudden rush!

We saw two dining rooms there: the one at the entrance, with its bar, and the one in the back. We got seated in the first one. It definitely had a rustic and traditional feel with its brick walls and the white and red table clothes. The service was quick and courteous that is sometimes missing in popular restaurants!
Image of the Dining room Lombardi's Pizza in NYC, New York - the oldest pizzeria in the US
I started off with an Italian Soda that is seltzer with vanilla flavored syrup and whipped cream.
Image of Italian soda at Lombardi's Pizza in NYC, New York - the oldest pizzeria in the US
This was the first time I tried this! It was interesting: the color of the drink itself was like crystal and had of course a strong vanilla taste thanks to the syrup. But the best was when mixing the whipped cream with the drink. It added more sweetness to it. Delicious, but not a drink I would crave!

Then we ordered a pizza: small size (6 slices) with wild mushrooms and homemade meatballs (beef and pork).
Image of Pizza at Lombardi's Pizza in NYC, New York - the oldest pizzeria in the US
The pizza, cooked in a coal oven, smelled amazingly good! The crust was thin and crispy with a nice char in the bottom and the sides.
Image of Pizza at Lombardi's Pizza in NYC, New York - the oldest pizzeria in the US
Each topping was $3 and they put a lot of it! The meatballs, although small, were moist and tasty.
Image of the Pizza at Lombardi's Pizza in NYC, New York - the oldest pizzeria in the US
They also did not cheat us on the wild mushrooms. Another thing I appreciated was the amount of basil they put on the pizza: usually, you get few leafs. At Lombardi's, they put a lot. This gave additional flavors to this great pie!

I definitely liked Lombardi's pizza! It is definitely a place to visit, with or without the title of oldest pizzeria in the US!

Be careful though: it is cash only, like when they opened...

Enjoy (I did)!
Lombardi's Pizza on Urbanspoon